Tuesday, December 13, 2005

Editing

Ok, so I'm an editor and the goal of any editor is to make sure that his/her work goes completely unnoticed.

What I love about editing is that it's where the story is really crafted... sculpted into shape. Every film begins with the script, and the more finely crafted the script, the more finely crafted the final product should be. A finely honed script allows for efficient budgeting, shooting... well the whole ball of wax.

Beautiful photography, brilliant acting, everything means nothing if the film isn't edited well.

There's a little game I play when I'm watching a movie. After the opening credits roll, I start counting the cuts and calling the shots. Medium shot. Single. Matching single. Wide. Master. You name it. I've found that if I can go 15 or so minutes doing this, well it's not a very good film. Why? Because I can pay attention to these niggling little details and not get caught up in the story. My suspension of disbelief is not engaged.

I rented Daredevil a year or so ago. I heard such awful things about it that I didn't go see it in the theaters even though it was my favorite comic when I was a kid. I think I got through about 45 minutes of calling shots on that film and was amazed at the number of sweeping cityscape shots utilized in the film. These shots served no purpose other than the bridge gaps between scenes that probably didn't cut together very well. They didn't add any new information to the story other than establish a location.... which 9 times out of 10 is completely unnecessary.

If you're going to set a scene in a church, there is, more often than not, no reason to show the church from the outside.... unless it's important to show the manner in which a character(s) enters the church. The audience should be able to figure out that the characters are inside a church because of the images used in designing the set. Arches, candles, pews, choirboys, crucifixes... etc. The audience can make huge leaps in their imagination and don't need to be spoon-fed little details. In fact, denying the audience these establishing shots usually helps to heighten the audiences' suspension of disbelief.

In this respect, Daredevil failed on all accounts. Even though it was a beloved comic book from my childhood, I could never enjoy the film because my imagination was never engaged.

There is an old editor's adage that states that a cut should not be made unless the next shot conveys new information. It's a very old-fashioned way of thinking about editing, but I think the core sentiment holds true. It's why I would love to edit a Woody Allen or a Robert Altman film. They work in long, highly choreographed master shots that use lots of dolly and jib motion to keep the shots from feeling static and lifeless. Editing those films is really about choosing the performance and crafting the pacing and tone of the film as opposed to creating a series of master and matching head-shots.

But today's audiences are pretty savvy in terms of how they process information. An audience today can accept a break in the stage line as long as it serves the need of the story. The French made jump cuts a regular occurrence. That's not to say that these tactics should be used willy nilly. They can and should be used when the needs of the narrative call for it. If you want the audience to feel a a little disoriented, well these are methods that would work, but simple, calculated shots always will work.

When I'm editing an assembly of a film, I always fall into the habit of over cutting the scenes and "cutting on faces". Cutting on faces refers to cutting back and forth from actor to actor as they says their lines. It's a very "television" way of cutting. I try not to stay in that mode of cutting when I'm refining the scenes, but it does help to give a sense of structure to a scene. From there you can get into overlapping dialogue which feels much more natural and helps smooth out the edits so they aren't as apparent.