Hello!
When photography was first coming into it's own, classically trained fine artists (sculptors, illustrators, painters, etc.), poo-poo'd photography as a second rate art because it wasn't an act of pure creation, but rather a "captured" medium. In essence it was a second-class citizen because "artists" thought that pointing and clicking wasn't as "meaningful" as crafting something from scratch on canvas or with clay or marble.
Well, 150 or so years later, we all know this to be complete and utter horse sh!t!
However, now we have digital versions of just about every art form. 3D modeling has replaced a lot sculpting in the film and video world. Digital photography is all the rage. And Digital video, HD in particular, is changing the way in which films are being made.
BUT!
Whenever you have a discussion regarding film vs. video, you will get into the age old debate as to whether film or video is better for feature filmmaking. It's almost always a heated debate. "Video sucks!", one will say. "Film is dying!", another will say.
To those of you who engage in grossly generalized arguments like this... PLEASE STOP! It doesn't accomplish anything.
35mm film is a beautiful thing. It's exposure latitude, color sensitivity and grain give it, well, a look that only film can provide at this point in time. Super 16mm is also a beautiful thing for feature filmmaking. Same aspect ratio as 35mm so it blows up well to a 35mm release print. But the drawback is your depth of field is greater, so you lose a little of the cinematic look that the selective depth of field 35mm lenses afford you.
The "film zealots" as I like to call them, are steadfast in their belief that it's not a movie unless it's shot on film... and 35mm at that. Even a fine format like Super 16mm is frowned upon. As it stands right now... yes, 35mm affords you the greatest exposure latitude, the best lenses and that wonderful organic feel that only film grain can provide.
However!
Digital video in all of it's formats is a wonderful thing as well. From Digital 8 through uncompressed 10bit 4:4:4 24p HD, the world of filmmaking is undergoing a revolution. More people are able to tell their story and at a price that is affordable. But then again, there are people who take the digital argument too far and say that film is dying. (people have been saying this about 35mm still photography for years, but you still find Kodak, Fuji and other brands of 35mm film everywhere!)
When it comes right down to it... whether shooting on digital video or petroleum/silver based film ( a toxic nightmare!), all that really matters is that you're telling a good story. I wish people would stop arguing over formats and focus more on story.
I know people who will not work on projects because it's being shot on video and others who, well, can't work on a project because it's film and they've never really learned how to light for film. I guess this really only applies to cinematographers and gaffers. A grip, wardrobe person, actor, etc. can all work in either medium because what they do isn't directly affected by their knowledge of how much light is required for exposure.
Film people can go either way because they truly understand how light works and how to manipulate it. To work in video, they merely need to learn the limitations of the particular camera they're using in regards to how it handles light and what it's exposure latitude is so they can light for it. They get the best of both worlds.
Video people with no background in film or photography will have a hard time with film because video is a WYSIWYG world. You plug the camera into the monitor, throw up some lights and check it against the monitor until you get what you want. There's no metering exposure, understanding film speed ratings, etc. And since you can get a decent exposure on video with a minimal amount of light, if you don't throw enough light at film, you underexpose and well, you have a useless negative and you've just wasted a crapload of money and have put a bunch of toxins into the environment for no good reason and have wasted a lot of peoples' valuable time.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that film zealots and video junkies can learn from one another. Film won't disappear, but it's status as "the one true medium" will diminish as digital video technologies advance. But film people can teach video people about light and how it works to craft an image that moves and affects people and video people can spread their infectious lust for the emerging tools and technology that are democratizing the art of filmmaking.
Lajos Egri, in his book, The Art of Creative Writing makes a claim that root of human drama is a person's need to feel important and to belong. Ultimately, I think this divide between analog and digital filmmakers is deeply rooted in this. Film people feel that their years spent learning a craft and the technical underpinnings of how light and film work together has earned them some "bragging rights" or prestige over their video brethren and video people think that their knowledge of emerging, cutting-edge technologies affords them the same.
Whatever! What matters is the story! As an editor, I could care less whether a picture was shot analog or digital. If the story moves me... format be damned. I don't care if it's VHS! (as long as the sound is good). In a lot of ways, an audience will forgive a less than perfectly crafted picture, but if the sound is garbage... the audience will be merciless, regardless of picture quality!
So, to all you camera people out there... film and video alike... harass your sound people! Don't let your images be ruined by generator noise, line level hum, refrigerators, etc.
Anyway, I guess I should say, "Can't we all just get along and tell good stories?" Film isn't dying and video is only going to get exponentially better as the years go by. Video people, go take a film class and learn about how light works, your video work will only get better as a result. Film people, begin to embrace digital technology. DI's and HD are here to stay and if you do not embrace them, you will become the dinosaurs, the luddites of of the filmmaking world... and your years of study and craftsmanship are necessary in the emerging age of digital filmmaking.
Ok, I'm gonna go duck under a table now.
Friday, December 02, 2005
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment